How do local communities respond when major infrastructure projects threaten their environment? How do local leaders respond to environmental conflicts, and what does this reveal about the future of leadership in place-based development?
This new study provides fresh insights into these questions by examining the pivotal role of local leadership in environmental disputes across France, set within a wider European context.
Local conflicts, national interests
From airports to motorways and nuclear power plants, large infrastructure projects often trigger heated debates and sometimes outright protest. These conflicts are more than local disputes: they reveal tensions between national economic ambitions and the environmental concerns of the population.
This new study examines three emblematic environmental conflicts in France in order to understand the underlying dynamics and highlight how formal leaders such as mayors and local officials, as well as informal leaders such as activists and scientists, influence the outcome of these conflicts.
Focus on France
France offers a particularly revealing picture in this regard. Compared to the rest of the EU, environmental conflicts are significantly overrepresented in the areas of nuclear energy and transport/infrastructure. Conflicts often arise at the regional rather than purely local level and frequently involve large national companies such as EDF, VINCI and SNCF.
What the research shows:
Using data from the Environmental Justice Atlas (EJAtlas), the authors examine three emblematic conflicts to illustrate how leadership dynamics unfold on the ground :
- The Notre-Dame-des-Landes (NDL) airport project
- The A45 motorway project
- The Fessenheim nuclear power plant
Each case highlights different tensions between development and environmental protection. In all three cases environmental justice organisations (EJOs), citizens, and independent experts played a pivotal role, often filling the gap left by fragmented or uncoordinated public leadership.
Key findings include:
- Leadership is multidimensional. Elected officials, activists, scientists, and citizen groups all contribute to shaping outcomes. In many cases, non-elected leaders emerge as credible figures who form coalitions, mobilise expertise, and influence public opinion.
- Fragmented leadership escalates conflict. When local authorities fail to present a united front, as in the case of the A45 motorway, public discontent grows and trust in institutions declines.
- Bottom-up leadership is important. Protest movements often develop their own governance and planning strategies, creating alternative visions for regional development. These initiatives demonstrate the importance of inclusive, local, and collaborative decision-making processes.
What this means for policy
This study makes it clear that environmental conflicts are not just obstacles to be overcome ; they are also indicators of democratic deficits and shortcomings in governance. It shows that new leadership models should :
- Involve a broader range of voices from the earliest stages
- Recognise the importance of locally embedded knowledge
- Enable collaboration across administrative boundaries.
A role for new governance models
In the context of climate change, resource scarcity, and the pursuit of sustainable development, it is imperative to reassess place-based leadership approaches. This study suggests that both formal and informal leaders need to find ways to incorporate scientific, ecological, and local expertise early in project planning. This can reduce the likelihood of conflict and help secure long-term investment.
This study demonstrates how local, strategic leadership can prevent conflicts, create infrastructure projects that are more widely accepted, and promote economic and social development.
The EU*Asia Institute: Shaping debates and informing policy
This research was first presented at the workshop "Leadership & Sustainability in Europe: Where Now, What Next?", hosted by the EU*Asia Institute at ESSCA in October 2023. The workshop provided a platform for early feedback and discussion that helped refine the final article and strengthen its policy relevance.
This reflects the mission of the EU*Asia Institute: to support rigorous, interdisciplinary research on European integration and to contribute to contemporary policy debates. By facilitating dialogue between academics and policymakers, the Institute aims to help develop more effective environmental policy strategies for the future.
The full study is available in open access:
Cabras, I., Llavero-Pasquina, M., Picaud-Bello, K., & Weber, G. (2025). Place-based leadership and environmental conflicts in the European Union. Regional Studies. https://doi.org/10.1080/00343404.2025.2486644
Photos: Blandine Le Cain on Flickr - photo 23 and 46 - CC BY 2.0 - Anti-Notre-Dame-des-Landes airport protest in Nantes, 22 February 2014




